Skip to content

Five Rules for YouTube Success (that I never follow myself!)

As someone who works in Marketing, and specialises in digital communications, I’m well versed in the rules for achieving YouTube success. I know what it takes to make your videos and your channel successful. Today, I’m sharing with you the TOP FIVE MOST IMPORTANT RULES FOR YOUTUBE CREATORS. Strangely, I never seem to follow those rules myself! And I explain why that is.

TRANSCRIPT

0:00:03.220,0:00:06.820
You may already know that I work in marketing.


0:00:06.820,0:00:13.120
I am reasonably good at my job, and one of
my specialisms is digital communications.

0:00:13.120,0:00:17.820
So why am I so bad at YouTube?

0:00:17.820,0:00:24.480
I know the formula for YouTube success,
but I always seem to do the opposite.

0:00:24.480,0:00:29.400
I know exactly what it takes to make my channel
popular. To make lots of money from my videos.

0:00:29.400,0:00:35.420
But you wouldn’t know it from the
way I’ve chosen to run my channel.


0:00:35.420,0:00:39.660
The formula for YouTube success, the
rules of the game, are really really simple.

0:00:39.660,0:00:42.320
And I’m going to share them with you.

0:00:42.320,0:00:43.740
Rule number one:

0:00:43.740,0:00:51.200
You’re supposed to pick a niche and then
you relentlessly focus on that one subject.

0:00:51.200,0:00:54.460
So you might decide you want to talk about technology.

0:00:54.460,0:00:59.380
Or you might focus on travel and tourism.

0:00:59.380,0:01:02.300
Or you could make your channel entirely educational.

0:01:02.300,0:01:06.860
Do cookery, or DIY, or makeup tutorials.

0:01:06.860,0:01:09.600
I haven’t done that though.

0:01:09.600,0:01:14.560
Instead, I’ve decided to make videos
about whatever interests me.

0:01:14.560,0:01:17.840
So, I love technology and gadgets
and I’ve made videos about that.

0:01:17.840,0:01:20.120
(Which nobody watches by the way!)

0:01:20.120,0:01:24.880
I love to travel. So I’m going to be making videos
about visiting different parts of the world.

0:01:24.880,0:01:26.500
I’m obsessed with politics.

0:01:26.500,0:01:30.520
So I’ve been making educational videos about current affairs.

0:01:30.520,0:01:34.340
Or angry videos complaining about
things that annoy me in the news.

0:01:34.340,0:01:37.340
It’s 100% the wrong strategy.

0:01:37.340,0:01:41.840
It’s the absolute opposite of what I should be doing.

0:01:41.840,0:01:47.160
I should be mining one particular niche and nothing else.

0:01:47.160,0:01:51.660
Instead, I’m just making videos on
subjects that happen to interest me.

0:01:51.660,0:01:55.400
I’m just making the kind of videos
that I, personally, would like to watch.

0:01:55.400,0:02:00.540
So, I’m personally completely ignoring
rule number one – the most important rule.

0:02:00.540,0:02:05.920
Because I’m just making videos
to entertain me and my friends.

0:02:05.920,0:02:07.700
Rule number two:

0:02:07.700,0:02:12.520
You choose a group of fanatical idiots,
and then you pander to them.

0:02:12.520,0:02:16.960
So, you might decide to make
videos just for right-wing idiots.

0:02:16.960,0:02:20.300
Or, you might decide to make
videos just for left-wing idiots.

0:02:20.300,0:02:21.760
And it’s really easy to do that.

0:02:21.760,0:02:26.942
Because idiots just want to hear their
own opinions verbalised again and again.

0:02:26.942,0:02:28.560
They don’t want facts.

0:02:28.560,0:02:32.639
They don’t want nuanced discussion
about complicated issues.

0:02:32.640,0:02:41.420
They’d rather you twist the facts into a simple
message that supports their existing political bias.

0:02:42.800,0:02:45.900
And this rule doesn’t just apply to politics.

0:02:45.900,0:02:49.360
There are many different kinds
of passionate fanatical idiots.

0:02:49.360,0:02:52.239
So, there’s religious idiots, of course.

0:02:52.239,0:02:54.879
Who just want you to tell them that their holy books,

0:02:54.879,0:02:58.879
and their holy prophets, are brilliant and perfect.

0:02:58.879,0:03:03.220
They just want to hear you say
that their choice is the best.

0:03:03.220,0:03:06.960
And they also want to be told that
all the other religions are false.

0:03:06.960,0:03:11.880
And that people who follow those other
religions are shameless hypocrites.

0:03:12.600,0:03:16.180
An echo chamber, that’s what they want. Like this one!

0:03:16.180,0:03:17.760
There are nationalist idiots, as well.

0:03:17.760,0:03:21.680
Who just want you to pander to
their patriotism and xenophobia.

0:03:21.680,0:03:24.660
The Americans want to hear that America is awesome.

0:03:24.660,0:03:27.700
And the Chinese want to hear that China is the best.

0:03:27.700,0:03:31.700
And the Indians want you to talk up their history and their culture.

0:03:31.700,0:03:35.440
Then there are the sports fanatics, who just
want you to talk about their favourite team,

0:03:35.440,0:03:39.360
or their favorite athlete, in a positive way.

0:03:39.360,0:03:44.320
The problem is that I won’t pander to idiots!

0:03:44.320,0:03:46.240
I just can’t bring myself to do it.

0:03:46.240,0:03:48.500
I love facts.

0:03:48.500,0:03:51.160
I prefer knowledge to ignorance.

0:03:51.160,0:03:52.740
I’m open to debate.

0:03:52.740,0:03:57.000
I’m also open to the possibility that I might be wrong.

0:03:57.000,0:04:01.200
And that means I will never appeal to stupid people.

0:04:01.200,0:04:05.960
Unfortunately, for me, half the
population are stupid people.

0:04:07.440,0:04:09.380
Rule number three:

0:04:09.380,0:04:12.720
If you want to make money from
YouTube, then make longer videos.

0:04:12.720,0:04:17.180
There’s a good reason a lot of YouTubers
make their videos just over 10 minutes.

0:04:17.180,0:04:19.100
That’s the golden number,.

0:04:19.100,0:04:24.460
Because, you get more advertising money
for your videos that go over 10 minutes.

0:04:24.460,0:04:28.400
That’s why people pad out their
videos with irrelevant bullshit.

0:04:28.400,0:04:32.160
Just to squeeze a little bit
more money out of their fans!

0:04:32.160,0:04:38.920
Me, on the other hand, I make my videos
as long as they NEED to be, and no longer.

0:04:38.920,0:04:41.520
If my video has nine minutes worth of content,

0:04:41.520,0:04:45.620
then I’m putting out a nine minute video.

0:04:45.620,0:04:48.740
In fact, I’ll be looking at that nine minute video and

0:04:48.740,0:04:52.220
I’m thinking about how I could make it even shorter.

0:04:52.220,0:04:57.800
Because I’ll be desperately trying to cut out
as much unnecessary material as possible.

0:04:57.800,0:05:03.840
And the reason for that is because I trained
as a journalist. That’s my background.

0:05:03.840,0:05:06.960
And we were taught to be as concise as possible.

0:05:06.960,0:05:09.285
“Get to the point. Don’t waste the audience’s time.”

0:05:09.285,0:05:12.000
That’s one of the first things I learned.

0:05:12.000,0:05:16.680
And, inevitably, with shorter videos
there will be fewer adverts.

0:05:16.680,0:05:21.020
So, I’ll be getting a lot less money from advertising.

0:05:21.660,0:05:26.280
Rule number four for YouTube success:

0:05:26.280,0:05:29.620
You’ll see a lot of YouTubers pretending to be excited.

0:05:29.620,0:05:32.200
Or pretending to be overcome with emotion.

0:05:32.200,0:05:35.780
And they do that because that’s the
fourth rule of YouTube success:

0:05:35.780,0:05:37.822
Give the audiences drama!

0:05:37.822,0:05:41.400
And the best way to give it
to them is to fake happiness,

0:05:41.400,0:05:45.120
or nervousness, or excitement, or fear.

0:05:45.120,0:05:48.480
And you can ramp all of those
feelings up with some loud music,

0:05:48.480,0:05:51.800
and lots of quick edits,
jumping from one shot to another.

0:05:51.800,0:05:55.100
It’s how a lot of video makers keep their viewers hooked.

0:05:55.100,0:05:58.860
It’s basically the McDonald’s of storytelling.

0:05:58.860,0:06:01.600
And don’t get me wrong.
I’ve got nothing against McDonald’s.

0:06:01.600,0:06:03.440
It’s successful for a reason.

0:06:03.440,0:06:06.040
It’s just not for me.

0:06:06.040,0:06:10.920
I have too much self-respect and dignity to pretend.

0:06:10.920,0:06:12.960
I don’t want to lie to you.

0:06:12.960,0:06:15.540
Because I think that’s disrespectful to you.

0:06:15.540,0:06:18.560
So I’m just going to be honest instead.

0:06:18.560,0:06:23.460
And I’m well aware that honesty
can be a bit boring sometimes.

0:06:23.460,0:06:26.040
But I prefer authenticity.

0:06:26.040,0:06:34.340
Unfortunately, authenticity and honesty isn’t
the best way to grow your audience on YouTube.

0:06:35.300,0:06:37.420
Rule number five:

0:06:37.420,0:06:40.820
Now there are many YouTubers
who make a hell of a lot of videos.

0:06:40.820,0:06:45.400
Some will even push out up to 10 videos a week.

0:06:45.400,0:06:51.920
And that’s because the YouTube algorithm
rewards you for releasing more videos.

0:06:51.920,0:06:56.160
And, because the algorithm is basically a machine,

0:06:56.160,0:07:00.200
it doesn’t know the difference
between quality and quantity.

0:07:00.200,0:07:03.740
As a result, you’ve got people
releasing hundreds of videos a year

0:07:03.740,0:07:08.639
where they say and do almost nothing of any interest.

0:07:08.639,0:07:14.639
I don’t entirely blame them because they’re
just playing the game as best they can.

0:07:15.360,0:07:19.039
Let’s say you work hard to
make 20 brilliant videos a year.

0:07:19.039,0:07:25.500
Chances are you’ll get less overall views than
if you just pump out 200 crappy videos.

0:07:25.500,0:07:29.820
And that’s especially true for people
with an established audience.

0:07:29.820,0:07:34.620
I’ve seen this happen so often on YouTube,
to some of my favourite channels.

0:07:34.620,0:07:38.440
Where someone who used to make a
couple of excellent videos every month

0:07:38.440,0:07:45.220
ends up pumping out hundreds of simple,
low quality, talking-to-camera videos instead.

0:07:45.220,0:07:47.400
And I really don’t want to do that.

0:07:47.400,0:07:52.780
I want to put some thought into
whatever gets released under my name.

0:07:52.780,0:07:55.640
I want people to actually get
some value out of my channel.

0:07:55.640,0:08:00.780
Ideally, I want people to watch more than once.

0:08:01.760,0:08:06.479
Even this video, which looks like a simple,
casual, walk-and-talk conversation,

0:08:06.480,0:08:10.100
is far more complicated than you might think.

0:08:10.760,0:08:14.639
I spent a whole week putting this together.

0:08:14.639,0:08:17.660
I made notes. I rehearsed.

0:08:17.660,0:08:18.960
A lot.

0:08:18.960,0:08:23.580
And what you’re watching right now
is not the first time I’ve filmed this.

0:08:23.580,0:08:28.120
I’ve actually put a lot of time and effort into this.

0:08:28.120,0:08:31.040
And I know it’s probably wasted effort.

0:08:31.040,0:08:34.399
But I’m doing it anyway. For pride.

0:08:34.399,0:08:37.120
So there you have it.

0:08:37.680,0:08:42.800
Five reasons why I will never achieve YouTube success.

0:08:43.500,0:08:47.540
Which is a depressing conclusion to end the video.

0:08:47.540,0:08:54.100
But, hopefully, some of you will
be able to learn from my mistakes.

Published inArts & CultureTechnology

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LEGAL NOTICES: Jay Shareef is a fictional character. You really should not believe anything you read here. This website contains affiliate links. We may receive a commission on any sales generated from them. All rights reserved. Copyright (c) 2025 Jay Shareef Enterprises.